As an interview coach, I talk to people in the depths of the recruitment process on a weekly basis. It’s rare for a week to go by without someone telling me that they thought they were doing really well and had a good chance of getting the job but then things changed. Communication ground to a halt, the job description morphed into something completely different, or they are being asked to go through rounds and rounds of interviews with no clear endpoint in sight.
All these are red flags. They are not about you or your capabilities but a reflection on how the organisation approaches recruitment and treats applicants which doesn’t bode well for what it would be like to work for them.
I’m not saying that you need to jump ship as soon as you notice red flags. It’s something to monitor in case the opportunity isn’t leading to anything or isn’t a good fit for what you’re looking for next in your career.
Here’s the guidance I give all my clients and a list of red flags to look out for during interviews.
Interviews Are a Two-Way Street
We put a lot of our time and energy into impressing recruiters. We spend hours researching the company and crafting a tailored CV. Then we diligently practice interview questions and refine answers that will position us as a great choice for the role. For guidance with your interview preparation, read my book ‘Be Better Prepared for Interview Success’. You can download a free chapter on how to answer why you want the job here.
As candidates, we do anything we can think of to show how we’d add value. But would taking the job add value to our careers and lives?
That’s a question that often gets overlooked, especially if we’ve found ourselves going through the job search process unexpectedly or it’s taking us longer than we thought. We just want to make sure the opportunity doesn’t slip through our fingers.
Interviews and the whole recruitment process are a chance for you to assess whether the job and organisation would be a good fit for you. Is it aligned with the workplace culture you work best in? Does it support your professional growth? Would you be able to leverage your strengths? All this is important to your career management and progression as well as your personal fulfilment.
Pursue any opportunities you can. Just remember, you don’t have to take all of them if they’re not ticking the boxes for you.
15 Red Flags to Look Out For in Interviews
Now, these could just be signs of disorganisation in the recruitment process. Although, organisations should always be thinking about their reputation and how they present themselves to candidates because it could determine the talent that applies to work for them.
These could also be signs that they are wasting your time and you’re unlikely to end up with a job offer or the kind of job that you’d hoped for. In that case, review how much effort you put into chasing recruiters and engaging with the process. You might need to move on to the next.
1. Lack of Preparation or Organisation
It’s usually quite easy to tell when an interviewer hasn’t reviewed your CV beforehand and is pretty much making up the questions on the spot. Simply, it’s not professional. It doesn’t set you up for success or help them properly assess your capabilities. This lack of professionalism in such an important process indicates internal disarray at the organisation.
2. Vague or Inconsistent Job Description
If the scope and salary are a bit ambiguous or keep changing and your questions don’t get you any more clarity, that’s a concern. How can you show that you’d be a good fit for the job without a proper description and how can they evaluate your suitability without knowing what they are looking for? Not knowing what they want and what salary they can offer you puts you in a difficult position.
3. Negative or Unsupportive Company Culture
Notice how the recruitment team talks to each other and about the rest of the team. This says a lot about their company culture and the level of respect and collaboration in the team. Negative comments can be a sign of a toxic company culture that would make it challenging for you to truly thrive in your role.
4. High Turnover or Frequent Openings
Have you noticed job opportunities at the company for the same or similar roles pop up frequently in your job search? High turnover suggests difficulties in retaining employees which is often due to poor work conditions such as management problems, negative workplace culture or unsustainable workloads. Definitely think twice about why they are hiring again.
5. Lack of Growth Opportunities
Always ask about development opportunities. If they don’t have routes in place for employees to advance, you could end up getting stuck in the role and have to move elsewhere to progress your career. Does that align with your career goals or would you like the option to grow at a company?
6. Unreasonable or Unrealistic Expectations
As you discuss the role with recruiters, do you feel comfortable with what is being asked of you? Right from the beginning, asking for too much from employees, such as excessive workloads, overtime expectations or vague goals with high pressure, is a sign of things to come. Being able to meet performance targets and maintain work-life balance is important to your professional development and personal fulfilment.
7. Poor Communication or Lack of Follow-Up
The recruitment process is never going to move at lightning speed. There are too many moving parts! But recruiters should get back to you in a reasonable time and keep you in the loop. Delays, ghosting and unclear timelines are not only frustrating but also show a lack of organisation and respect for candidates. It’s not a good start!
8. Trust Your Instincts
If something just doesn’t feel right, there’s probably a reason for that. Don’t ignore the feeling. Investigate further and move forward with caution.
9. Rushed Hiring Process
There isn’t a good reason that you shouldn’t have time to think over the job offer and consider your options. If a company is pressuring you to accept the offer and start straight away, there’s usually something behind that like desperation to fill the role due to high churn. There’s probably a reason they can’t keep the role filled.
10. Inflexibility on Work Arrangements
In today’s working world, it’s normal for there to be discussions about remote work, hours and time off. Flexible working is a perk many companies advertise. If they are closed to any kind of negotiation and have strict policies on work arrangements, this could be a sign of outdated or controlling management.
11. Lack of Diversity and Inclusion
It’s standard practice to address DEI in the hiring process. If this has been missed, it suggests that creating an inclusive work environment is not a priority for them. The diversity in leadership can also be a good measure of how important inclusivity really is to an organisation and whether or not it’s aligned with your own values.
12. Overemphasis on Perks
Perks can be great but extravagant perks can be used to distract from underlying issues like overworking and a poor culture. Most perks are nice to have. A positive work environment is a must-have so look for genuine signs of that behind any eye-catching perks. That being said, use websites like Glassdoor in a balanced way. It rarely tells the whole story because people go on there to leave reviews when they have a specific reason to do so. It usually reflects the two extremes, not much in the middle.
13. Excessive Interview Rounds
The recruitment process should be made clear at the beginning. But sometimes it seems like the goal posts keep changing. If you feel like you are moving blindly through multiple rounds of interviews, that shows a lack of organisation, communication and clarity on their end. Constantly changing decision makers or processes is usually due to internal chaos.
14. Dismissive of Work-Life Balance
Recruiters and interviewers should be able to answer questions about work-life balance and how the organisation supports the wellbeing of their employees. If these questions are avoided or even laughed off, it could mean that overworking is glorified and burnout is common in their work culture.
15. Vague Answers to Questions About Challenges
You should be able to ask genuine questions about where things stand at the organisation without being dismissed or mollified with a vague answer. If they are being evasive about turnover, team issues or current goals, they could be hiding something behind a lack of transparency.
Balancing Opportunities and Energy
Of course, there is nuance to this. Things change, key decision makers go on annual leave and mistakes happen. I’m not suggesting that you turn away any job opportunities when a recruiter takes a while to reply. Being open-minded about the opportunities we pursue can lead to beneficial career development in the most unexpected ways. But everyone should have a limit on what they are willing to put up with.
You only have so much energy to put into your job search. You don’t want to waste it on opportunities that don’t look like they will come to fruition or show signs that working at the organisation wouldn’t fulfil your needs or career goals.
Otherwise, you will struggle to maintain momentum in your job search and perform well in the recruitment process for job opportunities with lots of potential and green flags. Or you could get stuck in a job you don’t like and have to start your job hunt all over again.
Always reach out asking for extra information that you need to make your decision or updates on the timeline. If you don’t get a satisfactory response, move on. You deserve to be treated with consideration throughout the interview process. How they treat you at the start often reflects the company culture and the longevity and fulfilment of your job long term.
If you are feeling a bit lost in your job search, whether you’re struggling to find opportunities that go anywhere or are worried about your interview performance, book an interview coaching session. We can review your application strategy, refine your interview technique and discuss what questions you can ask to check that the job and company are right for you.